黄惠如
回复 蔡浩英 :阴阳路7：撞到正当红女歌星（李惠敏饰）随剧组到一荒凉小岛上为新歌的MV拍摄取景，坐在船中休息时总觉得水中有异物。小岛上住着为数不多的几户居民，民风淳朴却也相当愚昧。随着拍摄进程的不断，剧组内开始怪事不断。剧组人员周围总会突然莫名出现一奇怪的黑衣男子（古天乐饰）不断打探“阿莹”的下落。与此同时，荒山野岭内常有一长发怪人身影出没，嚎叫不断，让人毛骨悚然。一日，女歌星与导演再次撞到黑衣男子，大胆询问之下，男子道出了岛上的一段往事......本片宣称没有黑夜的鬼片，所有外景都是在白天完成，有其独特之处。
陈孟芬
回复 王丽刚 :校园突击MaskedfigureswithmachinegunsmarchintothesecondaryschoolinKaratas,takethepupilshostage,andexecuteoneofthem.Theymakenodemands.Silentterroristheirmodusoperandi.Seeingasthearmywilltaketwodaystoarriveduetoasnowstorm,mathsteacherTazshidecidestoassemblehisownassaultteam:hisex-wife,thegymteacher,thecowardlyschoolprincipal,analcoholicnightwatchman,thevillageidiot,andanincompetentchiefofpolice.Whatfollowsisnotraditionalactionfilm,butathrillerwithsnatchesofcomedy,inwhichtheenemyisn’thiddenbehindmasks,butisinthemindsoftheliberators.Beforetheyact,theyhavetoovercometheirpersonaldemons.Comparisonstotheschoolhostage-takingsinBeslanandKazanareobvious,yetKaratas–themythicalvillagewheremuchofdirectorAdilkhanYerzhanov’sworkisset–couldbeanywhere.Itisuniversallyacknowledgedthatcrisesbringoutpeople'struenatures.
